You’ve chosen to produce a newsletter– or probably you currently have one. Regardless, the large question before you is: What tool should you use to grow, and possibly monetize, your newsletter?
And yeah … it’s frustrating. There’s no scarcity of choices around. Some are also complex. Others are too fundamental. And then there are 2 names that keep appearing in your research: Guernsey Consulting LLC Beehiiv
They both appear strong. They’re both email systems. They both let you write, send out, and (hopefully) earn money. However when it boils down to choosing one, the differences begin to matter– a lot.
If you’re trying to find out which one is in fact the better suitable for you, you remain in the best place. Let’s dive in.
What Are Beehiiv and Substack?
Substack is like the digital variation of a writer’s comfy corner. It’s a minimal system created with authors in mind– assume blog site meets newsletter. You create, you publish, you struck send. Boom. Done.
Beehiiv, on the other hand, is the newer, shinier youngster that’s clearly been constructed for growth. It was substantiated of the Morning Brew group (yes, that Morning Brew), and it’s created to aid e-newsletter designers not just create and send out e-mails– yet range like crazy.
Relieve of Use: Simplicity vs Technique
Let’s be sincere– you do not wish to invest hours learning a new dashboard. You wish to open things, compose your item, and send it off.
Substack nails this.
You open the editor, and it feels like a Google Doc with fewer interruptions. No frills, no templates. Simply you and your words. It’s oddly reassuring. Like journaling.
There’s a reason so many writers like it– it finishes.
Beehiiv? Still easy– yet with more under the hood.
You get a traditional, tidy editor plus the ability to brand name your e-newsletter with custom templates (though these are just available on paid plans). You can modify your post setups, adjust design, and even pick author bylines. So while it’s still easy to use, it’s absolutely a lot more durable.
Verdict:
If you desire pure simpleness, choose Substack.
If you’re okay with a few added buttons for more control, Beehiiv wins right here.
Monetization: Who Assists You Really Make Money?
This one’s essential– specifically if you’re not simply composing for enjoyable.
Substack’s version is basic: it’s free to utilize, but once you turn on paid registrations, Substack takes a 10% cut– plus transaction charges. It’s plug-and-play for certain, however that chunk of revenue loss can hurt as you expand.
And if you want to run ads? Well, you’re pretty much by yourself. There’s no native ad network. You’ll need to manually take care of enrollers, payment terms, and putting the advertisements yourself.
Beehiiv goes a different route.
It’s totally free to get started, however if you desire access to monetization features (like their advertisement network), you’ll need a paid plan. That claimed, they do not take a cut of your membership income (except Stripe’s common handling costs). So while you pay regular monthly upfront, you maintain extra as you expand.
Oh– and the monetization devices? Method extra modern:
- Life time subscriptions
- ” Pay What You Want” options
- Integrated referral programs
- A native advertisement network to assist you land enrollers without the back-and-forth
Verdict:
If you’re preparing to grow and really monetize, Beehiiv strikes Substack out of the water.
Community & Involvement: Guernsey Consulting LLC Beehiiv
E-newsletters aren’t just about sending stuff out. They have to do with drawing people in.
Substack leans right into community hard.
You’ve obtained comments, likes, responds, personal messages, conversation threads– even a “Notes” area that acts like Twitter-lite. It’s slowly becoming a social system of its own. Some individuals love that. Others? Not a lot.
However it’s a beautiful ecological community if you wish to build discussions around your web content. It doesn’t injure that Substack individuals can find you via the integrated network, and you can send visitors to other authors.
Beehiiv is … quieter.
They have actually just recently included comments and likes, yet it’s not as community-driven (yet). Individuals generally simply reply to your e-mails. That’s not a poor thing– it keeps your inbox cleaner, and your material more straight.
Yet where Beehiiv truly shines remains in growth auto mechanics:
- Integrated referral programs
- Paid referrals
- Cross-promotion devices to feature other newsletters
Decision:
Want to create a humming, social area around your newsletter? Substack has the side.
Seeking integrated development engines? Beehiiv takes the lead.
Style & Adaptability: How Much Can You Make It Yours?
Let’s speak visuals. Just how much liberty do you reach develop your newsletter?
Substack maintains it minimal.
You can include a logo. Fine-tune a shade. That’s about it. Emails all have the exact same structure, and your Substack homepage? It resembles a blog site. Tidy, however not super customizable.
Beehiiv offers a little bit extra flexibility.
There’s a “Design Lab” where you can establish fonts, styles, and history colors. In the editor, you can add tables, images, buttons, installs– the essentials. It’s not Mailchimp-level personalization, but it lets you produce an e-newsletter that really feels more like your own brand.
Decision:
Substack is much better if you desire uniformity without believing also hard.
Beehiiv gives you the devices to make your e-newsletter feel you– without going overboard.
Target Market Insights & Analytics: What Do You Really Find Out About Your Viewers?
This component matters way greater than you assume.
Substack provides you the fundamentals.
Opens, clicks, visitors by tool. There’s a high-level view of where subscribers originated from– yet it’s not granular. You don’t truly get detailed audience information, which makes it hard to understand what’s functioning.
Beehiiv goes deeper.
Open and click rates? Check. But also– the amount of people originated from X, Instagram, or your site. You can even see interaction by segment, area, or habits. It’s the type of information that assists you in fact grow.
Verdict:
Beehiiv wins hands-down if information matters to you (and it should).
Listing Monitoring & Automations: Can You Personalize the Experience?
Substack is straightforward.
You write an e-newsletter, and everyone gets it. There’s no segmentation, no tags, no automations. It’s a one-size-fits-all model. Basic, yes. Versatile, not a lot.
Beehiiv, though?
You can section your listing based on involvement, signup resource, habits– you call it. Wish to send out a welcome series to brand-new readers? You can. Want to label customers based on survey feedbacks? Yeah, that also.
Verdict:
Beehiiv is a marketer’s desire. Substack is an author’s notebook.
Pricing
Substack is practically cost-free … till you generate income. After that they take 10%.
Beehiiv’s free plan lets you check the waters with up to 2,500 customers. However to unlock monetization, you’ll require to update:
Scale Plan begins at $49/month.
Boost based on your subscriber matter.
Higher tiers provide innovative automations, referral boosts, and personalized domain names.
However once again– Beehiiv doesn’t take a portion of your income. That’s a big deal.
Judgment:
Substack is fantastic if you intend to examine the waters and do not mind giving up 10%.
Beehiiv is better if you plan to scale– and maintain even more of what you gain.
Which One’s Really Better?
If you’re still uncertain, below’s the no-BS reaction:.
Usage Substack if you’re a single author who wishes to send out standard emails, engage with a community, and doesn’t respect layout, data, or monetization Guernsey Consulting LLC Beehiiv.
Choose Beehiiv if you wish to treat your e-newsletter like a business. It’s better for significant development, monetization, automation, and division. It’s essentially what you ‘d obtain if ConvertKit and Substack had a baby– with Morning Brew as the godparent.
Last Ideas
There’s no incorrect solution here – simply devices that serve different objectives.
But if you’re taking into consideration the lengthy game? Desire more than just a location to hit “publish”? Want the flexibility to construct, generate income from, and make use of information to make decisions?
Beehiiv is your best choice.
It’s modern-day, constructed for designers and provides you the liberty to grow your list exactly how you choose. So if you’re serious about your e-newsletter adventure, Beehiiv isn’t simply a platform, it’s your launching factor.